Anna: I seem to have gone against the grain in choosing NG. Anna certainly has a lawful "air" about her, but she doesn't follow the rules because she believes they're right--she follows them to avoid getting punished. She's shown a consistent willingness to break them throughout all the books (mostly because Alex is already breaking them, given, but still). I think Neutral fits.
David: NG, obvious.
Constance & Forbearance: LG, obvious.
Innocence: CG; in many ways she's "young Ozarker Alex" so this is pretty clear. I almost chose Chaotic Neutral actually, since she hasn't really done that much that's really "good," but I'll be charitable and assume it's due to lack of opportunity.
Julia: I went against the grain here and chose LG. She does occasionally bend the rules for Alex, but in general she strikes me as a "good girl" type who almost always follows the rules.
Max: Lol, answers all over the place here; I picked N. I think he has both LN tendencies (he is basically in the army after all) and CN tendencies (following his father), so I figured he averaged out to True Neutral. He's not evil, obviously, but not good either; he'll do anything for people inside his "circle" (family and friends), true, but consistently showed little regard for those outside it.
Darla: CN. Pretty obvious. The only other real option is NE, which is kind of unfair to her. She wasn't evil, she was a 14-year-old.
Larry: CN. I'm surprised True Neutral is the popular option here. Larry has never shown respect for the law or school rules, and indeed consistently breaks them (mostly for the sake of antagonizing Alex, true, but still).
Lilith: NG. This is fairly clear I think. She may be Dean, but she runs the school her way--she doesn't like the government poking its nose in her domain. At the same time, she does her best to help and protect her students (doesn't always succeed of course).
Diana: Wow, people don't like her. I picked LN, though honestly LG is just as likely. Destroying Alex's broom tipped the scales for me, but really, evil? Come on guys.
Shirtliffe: LG. Could be LN, but like with Innocence, I'll give her the benefit of the doubt.
Abraham: NE. Sorry guys, but "necessarily evil" is still evil. He killed dozens of muggles at the end of Book 2. I almost pegged him as LE, actually, since he does have some sort of moral code, but then I decided "revolutionaries can't be lawful." I kind of regret that now, really; a very good case can be made for LE.
no subject
Anna: I seem to have gone against the grain in choosing NG. Anna certainly has a lawful "air" about her, but she doesn't follow the rules because she believes they're right--she follows them to avoid getting punished. She's shown a consistent willingness to break them throughout all the books (mostly because Alex is already breaking them, given, but still). I think Neutral fits.
David: NG, obvious.
Constance & Forbearance: LG, obvious.
Innocence: CG; in many ways she's "young Ozarker Alex" so this is pretty clear. I almost chose Chaotic Neutral actually, since she hasn't really done that much that's really "good," but I'll be charitable and assume it's due to lack of opportunity.
Julia: I went against the grain here and chose LG. She does occasionally bend the rules for Alex, but in general she strikes me as a "good girl" type who almost always follows the rules.
Max: Lol, answers all over the place here; I picked N. I think he has both LN tendencies (he is basically in the army after all) and CN tendencies (following his father), so I figured he averaged out to True Neutral. He's not evil, obviously, but not good either; he'll do anything for people inside his "circle" (family and friends), true, but consistently showed little regard for those outside it.
Darla: CN. Pretty obvious. The only other real option is NE, which is kind of unfair to her. She wasn't evil, she was a 14-year-old.
Larry: CN. I'm surprised True Neutral is the popular option here. Larry has never shown respect for the law or school rules, and indeed consistently breaks them (mostly for the sake of antagonizing Alex, true, but still).
Lilith: NG. This is fairly clear I think. She may be Dean, but she runs the school her way--she doesn't like the government poking its nose in her domain. At the same time, she does her best to help and protect her students (doesn't always succeed of course).
Diana: Wow, people don't like her. I picked LN, though honestly LG is just as likely. Destroying Alex's broom tipped the scales for me, but really, evil? Come on guys.
Shirtliffe: LG. Could be LN, but like with Innocence, I'll give her the benefit of the doubt.
Abraham: NE. Sorry guys, but "necessarily evil" is still evil. He killed dozens of muggles at the end of Book 2. I almost pegged him as LE, actually, since he does have some sort of moral code, but then I decided "revolutionaries can't be lawful." I kind of regret that now, really; a very good case can be made for LE.