inverarity: (Go)
[personal profile] inverarity


Why we suck at security (but not as much as you think)




Cobra Commander

"I could too! I totally could!"


LOL at all the people going "OMG U R GIVING TEH TERRORISTS IDEAZ!" in response to this article about how to destroy the Internet.

Did they miss the part about how you'd have to somehow be capable of launching simultaneous, coordinated strikes at dozens of locations on nearly every continent? This is not something any terrorist group could remotely pull off. This is not something a nation-state could pull off. This is not something Cobra Commander could pull off.

Humans, in general, are very bad at risk assessment. We spend hundreds of millions of dollars preventing what Bruce Schneier calls "movie plot" scenarios, and it's not even because people involved in security and national defense are ignorant. For the most part, they are not, even at the policy-making level. But what they are is politically risk-averse.

Some days I am very tired, even while I am trying to do my little part to keep shit from getting blown up. I see billions of dollars going down a drainhole, and wonder why the fuck anyone should care about a little fraud, waste, and abuse of taxpayer funds on a level that amounts to filching pocket lint by comparison.

I work in the belly of the beast, and I like to think what I do matters and ultimately serves good more than evil, but sometimes I am very tired.




Go is a metaphor for my life





This was a game against MFOG playing at the 9-kyu level. I was black. Usually the 9-kyu player beats me (sometimes I'm still getting wiped out at the 12-kyu level), but I am occasionally beating it. This time, I won by 6.5 points.

I am now learning a few josekis. Not sure if it is helping; many go instructors recommend not studying joseki at all until you are a very low-kyu or 1-dan player.

What actually is helping me is playing MFOG with "cheating" enabled, i.e., "Allow editing." In other words, when I realize I have totally fucked up, I go back and replay that sequence, or sometimes I try to backtrack to the move I identify as the point where my game went south. Sometimes I find out that no, I cannot save that group no matter what I do, but I am starting to recognize some of the traps I lead myself into, and I am becoming slightly less hasty to make the obvious and wrong move rather than the less obvious but superior move.

This is making me a slightly calmer player, too. When I know it "doesn't count," I don't get so angry when I screw up. However, I still need to get online and play real players more.

(I did not cheat when playing the above game, btw. There were no take-backs.)

Date: 2012-05-25 06:25 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] jordan179.livejournal.com
The truly scary thing is that there are some potentially very effective terrorist tactics involving nothing more than handguns and improvised bombs, which I don't want to go into here because I truly don't want to give the wrong people ideas. In general, the mistake the Terrorists have been making in this war is that they are looking for glorious grand gestures: a steady campaign of low-level random atacks would probably work better and be harder for us to intercept. Another 9-11 would be difficult to pull off against an alerted country: proof of this is that they haven't been able to accomplish it.

Date: 2012-05-25 04:20 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shinygobonkers.livejournal.com
that article was a pretty fascinating read in any case

and lol yeah at the terrorist comments. means, it's about the actual means that adversary has, which as you say...

congrats on the win. i think a lot of what practice, of anything really, does is train that part of your brain that works intuitively/instinctively, which is faster at making connections that conscious thought...which is sounds like working through re-dos sometimes would help with.

Profile

inverarity: (Default)
inverarity

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    1 2 3
4 5678 910
11121314 151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 17th, 2025 05:20 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios